I never stated it wasn't real, or that it didn't even exist.
What I stated is:
I don't buy into the whole "teenage" thing
I say this because I've owned several dogs, and I just can't say that I've experienced any bad behaviour that could be attributed to a "teenage years" thing.
According to popular legend, no matter how well trained the dog, it's going to get a rebellious streak and test the limits. I can, with my hand on my heart, say that I just haven't seen it happen, even with my lesser trained dogs. Now that makes me the luckiest owner in the world, the best trainer in the world, or just one who believes that the teenage years issue is a little over-egged, and so doesn't go around expecting bad things to happen. (Tip: It's the latter.
)
However, there are those far more intelligent than I, who are far more qualified to say whether it exists or not. I don't dispute that it exists, as I have to presume their testing is sound, etc. What I dispute is the alleged chaos, the testing of will, the bad behaviour, and so forth, that is all too often attributed to such a thing.
I see it more as a self-fulfilling prophecy, whereby people are expecting it to happen and so they subconsciously alter their training, their manner, their expectations, and, more importantly, they have a ready-made excuse when the dog has an off-day. Humans do this in so many aspects of life, I don't see why the dog-ownership aspect should be any different.
Mr X gets a dog and is perfectly happy with it. Then one day, his dog runs away from him, despite never having done it before. He goes to a forum to describe his woes, and someone asks "How old is he?". "Oh, he's a year old or so", comes the reply. Then, usually without any further thought, comes the dreaded, "Ah, that's just usual teenage years behaviour. Oh yeah, you can expect much worse from him now he's in his teenage years. My Fido, oh the trouble we had....." So now the seed is planted and propagated, and the legend is secured once more. Worse still, Mr X has an instant reason for all the woes of the next few months, and doesn't need to bother looking to see if there are other reasons. He might also follow the naturally human route and lessen the training of the dog, believing that his efforts will be futile for the next few months. Thus, his problems will surely worsen. Not because of some "teenage years" behaviour, but because the expectation of them has caused him to change his behaviour towards his dog. Once again, the legend is secured.
I have to go by what I see and feel, not by what I am told. All the book links in the world won't change what I see with my own two eyes.
I'm afraid that I'm very much of the Silvia Trkman school of thought:
Books, videos and seminars are helpful, but no one knows your dog better as you do, especially after teaching him those 100 tricks and playing and walking with him every day, so… Trust your intuition and do what YOU think is best for your dog. Avoid those that think there is just one best way. Wary those that want to make you believe you need particular breed/method/handling tool/video in order to succeed.
Of course, she's specifically referring to training, but I see little difference in the actual point she's making.
Actually I think I'll air my future thoughts on the subject in Ellie's blog. I'm wise enough to know that I could never change a view that is held so firmly by so many millions, so there would be little point in me continuing to try.