Choosing A Breed

Discussion in 'Dog Breeds' started by kassidybc, Jul 17, 2014.

  1. kassidybc Experienced Member

    We are considering getting another dog (well, my mom is considering it, I would be all for it! ;) ). I love border collies, and would love to get another one, but my mom is wanting a small dog. You know, a dog that she can carry and that can sit in her lap (well, a dog that can actually fit in her lap. Trust me, Chloe tries! :p). But I want the energy and intelligence of a border collie. Basically, I want a border collie in a small package! Obviously they wouldn't be exactly the same as a border collie, they wouldn't have all the quirks of a border collie (gotta love them BC quirks :) ), but are there any small/toy breeds who have an energy/intelligence level similar to a border collie? I want a dog that I can teach a bunch of tricks to, and compete in agility (and other dog sports) with. My mom wants a little cuddle buddy that she can hold in her lap. Any ideas? I have been thinking about a Papillon, does anyone have any experience with them?
    Ripleygirl and 648117 like this.

  2. 648117 Honored Member


    or Lewis!

    But you can't have either of them!

    In reality I wouldn't worry too much about the breed, let your mom choose since she wants it to be her dog and then work with whatever you get.

    I did not pick any of our dogs and I'm now competing in agility, rally-o and obedience with both Holly and Lewis (I'm sure Skye would absolutely love agility and would be really good, but she is my mums and I said I would refrain from training her).
    Holly needs one more certificate to get her Advanced Rally-o title and Lewis needs one more Novice certificate to get his title (he's only been to one show so far as well). At the Rally-o show one of the judges was so impressed with Lewis that she said I should do obedience with him, I told her I have been for the last couple of months ;).

    Holly has CGC foundation and bronze so far. And as you probably know, Holly can do a lot of tricks. Lewis can do a couple (I haven't tried to teach him many though - he can spin, shake paw and jump through my arms).

    We are doing an agility champ show this weekend (Lewis' first). Holly will start entering AD events soon too. I seem to be known as the person with "that really fast little dog" at agility, she can get a faster time than a lot of dogs much bigger than her if she goes clear and it's the right course (she can do tighter turns than larger dogs).
    Lewis just started agility class about a month ago but he can do weaves and is improving in all areas really quickly.

    Lewis hasn't entered an obedience comp yet, but when he does I expect him to do well. Holly is very close to advancing from Special Beginners to Novice, she's had the required score a couple of times but there was a German Shep with a higher score :( so she came second :) . She can do all the required tasks up to Test C and CD level (heel on/off lead, straight recall, retrieve, scent discrimination, send aways, recall to heel position, down on recall, stand for temperament test, 5 minute out of sight stay, down-stay, sit-stay, stand-stay - I've probably forgotten some stuff).

    And as an added bonus...... Holly has just started a new sport!....... weight pull!
    Holly has great potential in that sport too. She had her first try last weekend.


    Holly = PugX, 6.7kgs
    Lewis = Pomeranian(?), 5.7kgs

    Both are small dogs, neither were selected for potential sporting ability/intelligence (there breeds were not really considered at all actually). I didn't get Lewis until he was 3 1/2 and he came with a few behavioural issues (they are much better, but still there, especially the not liking strangers bit), I've had him 18 months.
    Both are doing more than most dogs in our club, including all the Border Collies!

    So either I got incredibly lucky to end up with two super smart small dogs of completely different breeds.... or it really isn't just about the breed....

    But, to increase your chances of getting a dog to do sports with I would suggest not getting a terrier. Terriers can be very independent, I don't see them in any of our sports much. Although they could do them, they have the intelligence and energy, they would need a lot of time and patience. Also, I'm not sure terriers are all that cuddly.

    The top small breeds that I would suggest if you really want the sporting ability would be:
    Shih Tzu

    But I really do think that almost any breed would be fine. I would focus on what kind of dog I wanted at home rather than what it will be like at sports as the dog will spend most of it's time being a pet and only a few hours a week being a sports dog.
    Ripleygirl likes this.
  3. kassidybc Experienced Member

    Aw, I can't just have Holly or Lewis? ;) Thanks for the advice! It would be my dog, my mom is just picky about what lives in her house. Which is understandable.
    Ripleygirl likes this.
  4. southerngirl Honored Member

    What about a Jack Russell. I've heard they are real firecrackers.
    Miniature Poodle. These guys are smart and good at agility.
    Min Pin. Had one when I was little, she was a great dog.
    I've heard Cavalier KCS but they have a lot of health problems
    Shetland Sheepdog there size range from 14-27 pounds.
    kassidybc and Ripleygirl like this.
  5. running_dog Honored Member

    Papillons are reputed to be the border collies of the toy dog world.
    kassidybc likes this.
  6. Ripleygirl Experienced Member

    I have heard that too! No personal experiece of owning Papillons though...
    kassidybc likes this.
  7. Ripleygirl Experienced Member

    What about a Hungarian Pumi, have a look back at Guess the breed thread....
    kassidybc likes this.
  8. southerngirl Honored Member

    I think they are hard to find in the U.S, which I believe is where Kassidy lives.
    kassidybc and Ripleygirl like this.
  9. Ripleygirl Experienced Member

    Hadn't though of that...! :whistle:
  10. kassidybc Experienced Member

    Thanks for all the ideas!

Share This Page

Real Time Analytics