A comprehensive guide to commercial dog food.
Feeding your dog is the most fundamental way to care and to promote a healthy life for your dog. Good nutrition will help your dog fight diseases and to keep him healthy.
It is of no surprise that the majority of dog owners spend more money on dog food than any other expenses for their dog. But choosing a brand or type of dog food can sometimes be confusing. A dog food that has a label “Premium”, “Premium Ultra”, or “Holistic” does not guarantee that the food was prepared using high quality ingredients. So the more you know about commercial dog foods and what the label means, then it become easier for you to choose the best brand for your dog.
There are basically two choices of commercial dog foods. There is either the kibble type or the canned type dog foods. Both contain mostly the same ingredients, but the kibble type had the water removed through the process of extrusion or baking. This gives the dog food a crunchy appeal while at the same time ensuring a long shelf life. The water is kept in canned dog foods, so it must be sealed in a can to keep it fresh.
Here are some Pros and Cons of both:
Kibble:
- Less expensive than canned dog food.
- Has a very long shelf life.
- Does not require refrigeration after opening.
- Available in many flavors, types and formulas.
- Usually keep teeth cleaner.
- Ability to buy in bulk.
Canned:
- May contain more vitamins & enzymes due to the fact that the food did not go though the process of extrusion.
- Long shelf life (with the can unopened).
- Easier to chew and picky eaters like it better.
- Must refrigerate any remaining food.
The label on the packaging can tell you a lot of information regarding the quality of the dog food. On the front you should see the brand of food, whether it is for puppies, adults or seniors. But also on the bag, you will find additional text that will describe in greater details the content of the food. This is usually found in the back or the side of the bag of kibble.
Within this text, you should find a list of ingredients that was used to manufacture the dog food. Although the amount of each ingredient is not listed, the manufacturers must list each ingredient in descending order according to weight. So if the first ingredient on that list is rice, then the food contains more rice than any other ingredient. If chicken is the first ingredient, then there are more chicken than any other ingredient. Dogs require a high-quality protein so they usually do better on dog foods that have meat ingredients listed in the first two ingredients.
Below is a list of common ingredients found in dog foods along with a short description:
- Animal fat (Chicken or Beef): Fat obtained from the tissue during the process of rendering and extracting.
- Grains: This usually includes one of the following: whole, ground, cracked, barley, wheat, rice, oats, brown rice or any other grains.
- Meat by-products: The parts of slaughtered mammals other than meat. This includes lungs, kidneys, brains, livers, blood, bones and intestines.
- Meat or fresh meat: The flesh which includes muscles, tongue, heart and skin.
- Poultry: The flesh and skins of poultry, it may include bones or not.
- Poultry by-product meal: The rendered parts of poultry, this includes necks, feet, intestines.
As you can see from this list, it is best to avoid the dog foods which contain by-products. Usually the more expensive brands of dog foods contain better ingredients, but you should always read the list of ingredients.
Also, the majority of dog food manufacturers will print their website address on the packaging, which you can usually find additional information about the brand and dog food, like how it was prepared and whether or not it contains by-products.
If you are currently feeding your dog a brand of dog food and you wish to switch to a new brand, you will first need to transition your dog to the new food. Begin by mixing your dog’s daily food amount with half of the new brand and half of the old brand. This will usually avoid diarrhea and other common problems that occur when changing dog foods.




What I DO see worth avoiding in the list is GRAINS. If dogs were in the wild, I can not imagine a dog seeking out some corn, or chomping on some rice. Grains are an unneccessary ingredient. They're simply added to dog food to bulk it up (give the illusion of more), but dogs do not digest grain very well. In fact, some grains, like corn, are common allergns.
I understand this is advice for commercial dog food, but the best dog food is that without grain. I would avoid dog foods with grain in them before I avoid them with 'by products'.
http://www.the-puppy-dog-place.com/d...mparisons.html
As far as common allergens go, I have not seen any hard evidence that it is corn that dogs are commonly allergic to. Even if it were true, many people are allergic to penicillin, but it is still an important antibiotic. So, as long as an animal is not allergic to corn, then I don't see why that animal has to avoid corn.
My own dog has food allergies. I'm very careful about what I give her to eat. I haven't actually tested out what she might be allergic to, but I don't give her anything that includes wheat, corn, whey, or chicken, only because she was not tolerant of a diet that included those things. She may be allergic to any one of those items, or all of them. Part of the problem is that most dog foods do contain those items, so people think these are common allergens. But, she could be allergic to only chicken. I also know dogs who are allergic to lamb.
The really important thing in my mind, is that American commercial food labels should contain some statements like "formulated to meet AAFCO standards." AAFCO is the American Association of Feed Control Officials who "provide a mechanism for developing and implementing uniform and equitable laws, regulations, standards and enforcement policies for regulating the manufacture, distribution and sale of animal feeds; resulting in safe, effective, and useful feeds." (taken from the website aafco.org). Even if the evaluation isn't perfect, at least we have some way to compare apples to apples, as labels and claims can be so misleading.
Mary
Please check you sources - here are two which contain scientific fact based on jaw composition and other biological factors:
(I couldn't post links yet but google dogs: omnivores or carnivores and check those links)
While dogs are able to survive if they eat certain vegetables, they will not thrive without meat. Moreover, all dogs should stay off of grains and be fed on a low to no grain diet. We feed a mix of Canidae which contains hypoallergenic brown rice, and Evo Red meat, which is grain free. We will be switching to a supplemented RMB, or Raw Meaty Bone, diet at one year of age. Please, please, please, for the health of our great companions do not spread mis-information. Dogs, all breeds, are carnivores and need have a meat based diet in order to thrive and live healthy lives.
According to Rebecca Remillard, DVM, a Specialist in Veterinary Nutrition:
"Canines are in the order Carnivora, but I think their feeding behaviors are best described as omnivorous. The term carnivore applies to their taxonomic classification, not their feeding behavior. Taxonomically, dogs are members of the order Carnivora, a very diverse group, that includes 12 families of more than 260 species, some of which are herbivorous mammals (the panda). There are three types of feeding behavior (omnivorous, herbivorous and carnivorous) all of which can be found among different members of the order Carnivora." (From an email response to the question of dogs being looked upon as carnivorous or omnivorous in the newsletter of the American Academy of Veterinary Nutrition.)
Even the American Academy of Veterinary Nutrition seems to debate the true classification of the nutritional taxonominy of Carnivore vs Omnivore. Perhaps it's best to say, feed your animal based upon it's individual needs and apparently dogs will thrive on a diet that combines various elements ( since I'm not a veteranarian I must defer to the Specialist in Veterinary Nutrition ).
Take care all: Hivin
To be fair, I also searched under "dog carnivore" and got lots of hits about genetic studies - not too interesting. Under the search of "canis familiaris omnivore" you'll get some hits, but one that stands out is this one written by scientists from University College London, University College Medical School, Institute of Zoology, and Cardiff School of Biosciences. The abstract indicates "Not all members of the order Carnivora are carnivorous. Some are omnivorous, and a few, such as the giant panda, Ailuropoda melanoleuca, are almost exclusively herbivorous." The title of the article is Differential Enzyme Targeting As an Evolutionary Adaptation to Herbivory in Carnivora.
In case you are wondering whether giant pandas have teeth that look like carnivores or herbivores, I found a picture at www.skullsunlimited.com/carnivores.htm. (or http://www.skullsunlimited.com/graphics/bc-29-lg.jpg) Scroll to the bottom to find the panda. Notice the huge canine teeth.
So, what this seems to indicate is, despite the type of teeth an animal might have, what it eats will indicate whether it is an omnivore or herbivore, etc. If it makes you feel better, I'll modify my previous statement to say that canids are omnivorous despite being in the order carnivora.
I've fed Charlie EaglePack Holistic Chicken Selects for about 2.5 years with no problems. He's very healthy and athletic, and stays in good weight (though I feed about 4 cups/day, more if he's getting extra exercise).
In February I didn't place an order in time, so I asked what brand was similar at the healthy-pet-food-store (not one of those big chain stores that thinks Science Diet is the way to go, lol). It was recommended that I try Canidae because the ingredient list is fairly similar... I have nothing against Canidae, but it did *not* work for Charlie.
He lost about 5 lbs in less than two weeks, eating 6 cups/day... he's not a big dog and I keep him lean anyways, so he was quite thin.
When I went to pick-up the EaglePack the store owner was shocked - she'd never seen that result, especially in such a short time. She suggested switching him to a grain-free diet, and gave me enough free samples to last over a month! 1/2 Taste of the Wild, 1/2 Timberwolf Organics. TOTW was nice, but I'm not sure I would switch from EaglePack other than it's easier to purchase (doesn't need to be ordered specifically). Timberwolf was amazing!!! I'd love to feed it, but I'm not rich yet, lol.
Over that month Charlie gained his weight back eating 4 cups/day, then maintained a nice weight on the same amount. He is a Poodle and can be a picky eater - not in variety, but in amount - he didn't feel a need to eat more than the 4 cups of the high-quality kibbles.
I then put him back on his EaglePack and he has been doing fine as always.
I don't feed him 'table scraps', but he does get other stuff a couple times a week... raw meat, fruits, veggies, grains... except foods that are considered toxic I'll give him anything - whether he eats it depends on his mood
I got the formula for high performance dogs, Wild and Natural, at 36% protein.
The kibble is really small and 'solid' (like Wellness cat food), as opposed to the cracker texture that some cheap kibble has. Charlie loved it but couldn't gulp it down, and wanted to crunch every piece. Charlie bloated last summer, so the fact that he is eager but not swallowing air is a relief.
They also put TONS of herbs in it and it smells *great*. Don't laugh at me but I tried one... it didn't taste as good as it smelled, but it wasn't too bad. It had a definite crunch so I'm sure it does a good job keeping teeth clean. I didn't like that it felt like I had large grains of sand in my mouth after I had ground it up, but I doubt dogs get that feeling due to the shape of their mouths - and maybe that's how all kibble is... I never had the urge like I did with Timberwolf
See if you can get a sample bag - I think you'll know what I mean when I say it's on a totally different scale
the brand is NATURE'S VARIETY and the Prairie or INSTINCT canned foods (her favorite flavors are the chicken/turkey and the Beef) they also offer duck, venison and rabbit!
While this is a cooked canned food, it has the omega fatty acids, is human grade food (it smells wonderful!) and has veggies and fruit in there as well as vitamins, minerals, all the essentials for good foundational nutrition.
They also offer a Prairie or Instinct kibble diet which is grain free - and I am hoping to get to try it- I signed up at Nature's Instinct Website and they gave me a coupon...
(To this point she WON'T eat kibble of any kind that I have tried) ... so I keep looking -
I like the fact that Nature's Instinct is all "grain free" and has NO by-products.... only the good stuff is in this brand of food.... so it's a great start for us.
I have been reading about the EVO foods as well and they also sound great!