Alright, well, we are having a dilemma. We need something to use as treats. I have been giving her venison jerky bits for dogs, and they are great treats, but with the amount of training we do we go through an 11$ bag in a week or two. I can't afford to keep buying them all the time. So, I need a cheap, healthy alternative. She is trying to lose weight (although she has already lost 3 or 4 pounds! Yay!) so it should be fairly low calorie. The treats I have thought of using are- Cherios Unsalted unbuttered popcorn I haven't used any of those yet, because I didnt know if they were safe. Would those be safe, healthy alternitives? Do you guys have any other ideas for treats? Carrots don't work, she just chokes on them, if I cut them small enough that she won't choke on them she isn't very motivated by them.